今晚的8TV绝对superstar成绩出炉了，有点大跌眼镜！既然是Kay郭晓薇胜出，这没天理！从一开始我都觉得Hau是可以胜出的，他有先天条件就是那有技巧的歌艺和一把动听的歌声。真想不到既然输给声音不出色而只有样貌的Kay。真替Hau徐仕豪深感不值！
也让我有点怀疑Superstar的定义在那里？难道有舞台和美貌就可以登上宝座了吗？那些评判员只会看进步空间和感觉，现在是比赛阿，你以为是练习吗？哇唠。。。看了真觉得不公平！开口闭口都说感觉，我看你们看到Kay甜甜的笑给迷倒了，她选的歌曲都是幼稚园的小孩都会唱，一点难度和水准都没有！ 别破坏马来西亚的水准！虽然Kay是进步了，但是我本人觉得她的歌艺不是那样出众，好像称不上是冠军呀？ 声音都没力度，有点懒洋洋的唱腔。但是评判员就说：很甜啊！
难道谁的唱片的销量多就谁赢了？那为什么还要让观众投选呢？浪费我们的金钱去投选阿？既然你们都有答案了，还叫观众投选干嘛?最后都没有公布投选的票数，那算什么？背后搞鬼吗？这成绩有多真实？也都是Superstar制作单位的决定罢了。真不可思议！
Hau, 虽然你并没赢，但是你还是我心目中的绝对superstar。别弃馁，你是能唱的！加油！
我想，8TV绝对superstar最好还是换形像师和舞台师做评判吧！别讨论歌艺了，讲来讲去歌艺都不放在第一。还是去选明星更适合不过！
I was so disappointed with the 8TV superstar result at 3/5/2008 unexpectedly Kay won in the contest. From the starting to the end, i would think that Hau is much more capable than Kay because Hau has a good and touching vocal which Kay only has nice appearance and good eye contact in stage performance.
During the whole programme, i felt that the result was out of expectation. All the judges were quite support Kay on that night, they praised Kay has a sweet vocal and sweet smiles and so on.
I found that their expectation on Hau is more higher than Kay, those judges chosen the difficult song for Hau. In the competition, you will found that different behavious towards them, it is not fair to contestant. Maybe those successful singer need to go through a lot of obstacles along the success path. It may good for Hau also.
Kay is a smart superstar because she really has a good sense in choosing song. But compare to Hau, those songs are non-compatible and lighter than Hau song. For my opinion, still not reach the standard yet.
Anyway, i really do not understand the objective behind 8TV superstar programme, are they looking for talent in singing rather than seeking for good looking and excellent in stage performance? It is difficult to find the balance between talent and appearance. Do you have any idea?
Is it possible that whose album best seller will be the winner? Then why still asking audiences to vote for them if the organisers have the answer already? How reality is the voting result? They even didn't announce the actual voting number for us also.
Maybe this programme merely doing something to earn money, they do not care about qualified talent in singing. The superstar is someone looks similiar a star, it is not important of their talent probably the important thing is the overall performance must be average.
Saturday, May 3, 2008
8TV绝对superstar定义何在？
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
8 comments:
你酱厉害，去当评审说评语啦！去登报纸投诉啦！不要在这里说风凉话！只是你自己认为HAU厉害罢了吗！很多人都不认为啊！HAU唱歌不感动人，如果感动得到的话，就算KAY的美貌再美，大家也会把票投给HAU的！总而一句，KAY&HAU都好，不过KAY最好！！！
说那么多风凉话做么？你要是有本事，你去当评审说评语！在要不然去登报纸投诉！我看你是第一个被淘汰的人！绝对SUPERSTAR只有一个，就是KAY!!!
this is just because more ppl willing to see Kay to win rather than Hau. It's nothing to do with the 8TV and the programme. You should ask why more ppl prefer Kay instead of ask what is the main objective of Superstar.
*actually their main objective is MAKING MONEY. Don't forget that.
If those who vote for Kay also is Jay Chou's fans, please don't contradict to yourself. Although his (Jay Chou) appearance is normal, he can write songs and many other things. This makes him famous because of his strong points. Until now still got some critics about him although he's famous and he's still improving and back up his weaknesses.
Let see, history repeats itself eh? Why 8tv's Malaysia Idol only has 2 seasons? First season Jacklyn and second season is Daniel. Why?
Read this sentence that quoted out from Malaysia Idol in Wikipedia.org:
It has been suggested that this is due to many of its viewers protested Lee's win and feared that another bad singer might win, and 8TV were unable to gain rights to produce the programme due to its excessive cost.
So if you wish history repeats itself. Sure go ahead! No chance for Malaysia to glorified their entertainment industry.
KAY Fans, a blog is meant for the authors to express their thoughts. Why request the author to publish in newspaper instead?
I agree that such program is meant to make money and they definitely achieve its purpose. There was one show where someone I knew participated. The parent actually bugeted RM 50 000 to vote for her through SMS. So, getting more vote does not necessarily means getting more support.
I somehow wonder if there is proper auditing of votes. I do not see the actual figure being published. Even if they are however, we cannot be certain the number is true.
Regarding Malaysian Idol, I supposed the phrase "excessive cost" refers to paying for the franchise "Malaysian Idol" and not necessarily production. Why pay loyalty, etc. when you can organize a similar program with a different name, isn't it?
Just my two cents.
All the while, except Astro's talent search reality show, all other talent search reality show have lost its main purposes. Look at what most Malaysians want. They prefer good looking than talented ones and they crazed over those hunks and chicks. At the same time most of the TV stations like 8tv successfully grabbed most Malaysians' appetite by broadcasting talent search reality show that bring up those good looking face individuals. If so why bother to have talent search shows since its lost its purposes compare with Singapore's PSS?
i will always support hau... for the section that duet with Guang Liang, i prefere Hau's than KAY one, the judges says that kay's is better, they said her voice is sweet when she sang "dui ni you gan jue", but do you realize that Guang Liang face turn black already, especially the last 2 choruses, i can't even hear Guang liang's voice, her voice is too loud until i can't here guangliang's voice, but Hau's different, he control his voice well he didn't dominant the song like kay, so it's more comfortable to listen than kay's one. this is the paet that i don't satisfy the most( this doesn't mean that i satisfy with the other's result) the only thing i can accept in this show is guan qi yuan's comment, especially the last speech he made: "我想HAU赢，但是我觉得KAY会赢。"
Perhaps those who voted Yes must be blind or deaf. This is malaysians' standards. LoL.
Post a Comment